Real Fudge {Recipe}

When I was in primary school in the late 1980′s, I created my first recipe book. It was a “reporters notebook”, ringbound, with a model posing as a cowgirl on the cover (I cut it out of a magazine).  It had an index, featuring basic recipes like meringues, cheese scones, pecan nut cookies and fudge – the recipes were all hand written, complete with hand drawn full colour pictures galore.

To my horror, I recently discovered that I had lost that recipe book. I wanted to make the featured recipe for fudge – a recipe that I had found on the wrapper of a Nestlé condensed milk can many years ago. I frantically searched for the book, but no luck. It must have fallen through the cracks of my very unorganised book shelves, or maybe somewhere in the garage, or upstairs where I recently tried to clean up some office space. The point is, I hope it is still somewhere in my house, temporarily hiding from me. I’ll hopefully find it when it is time to move house again in a few years.

Then I found the original Nestlé fudge recipe online, thank heavens. It was exactly as I remembered, simple and old fashioned. It had a quote at the top: “I have lost and found this recipe so many times I am finally committing it to Zaar. From Fair Lady, May 14, 1986″. It was the right one.

So here we go: I’m sharing this recipe as one of my all-time favourites. It is proper fudge, the real deal, melt-in-the-mouth. Save it!

llse -The Food Fox

 real fudge recipe 005 Real Fudge {Recipe}

Real Fudge Recipe:

Ingredients:

  • 1 (385 g) can condensed milk
  • 500 ml (2 cups) sugar
  • 25 ml golden syrup
  • 75 ml water
  • 60 g butter
  • 5 ml vanilla essence

Method:

  1. Put sugar and water into a large heavy saucepan. Stir over a low heat until the sugar has dissolved.
  2. Add the butter and syrup and stil until the butter has melted.
  3. Add the condensed milk and stir until it comes to the boil.
  4. Boil very slowly on low heat, stirring every minute or 2, until soft ball stage (the mixture will darken to a deep caramel colour and will start to form sugary crystals on the sides, sounding like sand when you scrape it).
  5. Remove from the stove, add the vanilla and beat it with a wooden spoon for 5-10 minutes until it starts to thicken (beating the fudge will ensure a great texture when completely cooled)
  6. Pour into a greased pan and leave to cool.
  7. Cut into squares when cold.

Download recipe card here

Looking for wedding and lifestyle inspiration? Be inspired by our Weddings

View Post Tags

I really love food. I love it so much that I want to be surrounded by it every day. That means eating it, dreaming up menu’s, shopping at markets, reading lovely food magazines, paging through my collection of recipe books, writing my blog and tweeting about my food adventures.

  • http://Website Lauren

    Thank you so much! I have been craving REAL fudge for about 2 weeks now! Can’t wait to try it!

    • http://www.thefoodfox.com Ilse

      Hi Lauren, hope you enjoyed your fudge fix! :)

  • http://YourWebsite Frankie

    I am delighted to see this post! I had the same (traumatic) experience during my long weekend bake-athon! (My old-school fudge recipe : totally MIA!) Yikes! Which I only realised after buying my can of condensed milk. I searched high and low in old cook books and even the Huisgenoot Website! Alas! So, as I sign of mourning the loss of my recipe, I had to have the condensed milk. (off course!). So, tomorrow I will walk down to the store and buy another can of condensed milk. This time, with less damaging consequences, as the fudge will be given away as a present! Thank you for sharing the recipe!!

    • http://www.thefoodfox.com Ilse

      Hahaha, Frankie – I love your approach of drinking the condensed milk when all else failed! It would have been my approach too. :)

  • http://www.yummyinspirations.blogspot.com Jolene

    Looks incredible! Must try it!

  • http://Website Shirley Briedenhann

    Your Comment

  • Pingback: Real fudge « The Food Fox

  • http://www.inariephotography.co.za Inarie Dreyer

    Thank goodness!
    It seems as if this recipe is one elusive lady! I’ve also lost my original copy of this exact recipe – the only kind of fudge in my opinion as it just has the best sugary rich taste. I am printing it right now and putting it in my new recipe folder.

  • http://YourWebsite Chantal Versfeld

    I also lost my original copy of this recipe (Fair Lady, May 14, 1986). Thank you so much for posting it!

    • http://www.thefoodfox.com Ilse

      Hi Chantal, I’m so glad to let you know that I finally found my original little book again! Stil containing the original cut-out from the Nestle can. So happy about it! :)

  • http://YourWebsite Donovan

    I have never made fudge before, but this recipe worked perfectly and the result was really good. The kids (and I) loved it. Thanks for posting it.

    • http://www.thefoodfox.com Ilse

      So glad to hear that, Donovan! Big pleasure!

  • http://www.ipdesign.co.za Duncan

    Was itching to make a proper fudge the whole month for our son’s B day. Way too many crappy recipes out there, then there is this one, now I’m no cook but this one takes the cake on all counts. It is simple and tastes soooooooo good. i know the kids will love it this weekend :) thanks for sharing, you’re a star!

    • http://www.thefoodfox.com Ilse

      Huge pleasure, Duncan! It sure is a classic recipe. :)

  • Penny

    Dear Lifesaver of note, thanks for sharing this awesome recipe! My daughter needed a batch of fudge for her market day at school but insisted on my mom’s old school recipe…big problemo, it was nowhere to be found! You can imagine my delight when I came across this easy-to-follow-hassle-free REAL fudge recipe…it totally saved the day soooooo thanks a stack xxx

  • Desiree de Goede

    YES!! this is the recipe I remember from my childhood – I used to make this with my mom, all the time! Thank you – I owe it to myself and all who know me to make this recipe tonight!! lol – I think I am now obsessed with it, lol – thanks so very much!

  • Samantha Dupavillon

    I have to echo so many of the comments here. I have been serching for this recipe for ages. My mother has it but she swears blind she cant find it, I dont believe her :-) I have been given so many fudge recipes and none of them come anywhere close to the taste or the memory of helping my gran bake for Sunday afternoon tea time. Thank you so much

  • celeste

    thank you so so so much for this